WHich one should i get?

Truthfully neither. Both would need an experienced rider to train them. I would get a healthier horse that's had alot of experience and is sound. Eventually you would be paying really expensive vet bills that would be much pricier then a good horse. You wouldn't be able to go really far with them and it even says that the first horse should only be lightly ridden. Unless u want 2 use them as just a backyard pet then srry i really don't recommend it :(